A Timeless Classic: “Only You (And You Alone)” by The Platters
“Only You (And You Alone),” often affectionately shortened to “Only You,” is a quintessential pop ballad composed by Buck Ram and immortalized by The Platters with the velvety lead vocals of Tony Williams. First recorded in 1954 for Federal Records, the song didn’t see the light of day until it was re-recorded in 1955 after the band moved to Mercury Records. This second recording marked the beginning of an enduring legacy, becoming a major hit and cementing The Platters’ place in music history.
The journey of “Only You” is a fascinating one. The initial 1954 recording went unreleased, but a year later, on April 26, 1955, The Platters revisited the song. This time, the magic was undeniable. When the track was released in May 1955, it quickly soared to the top of the charts, holding the number one position on the U.S. R&B charts for seven weeks and peaking at number five on the Billboard Top 100 chart. Its charm endured for 30 weeks on the charts, outshining a rival cover by The Hilltoppers.
The story behind the song’s success is as captivating as the melody itself. According to Herb Reed, The Platters’ bass singer, the group had struggled to perfect the song. During a car rehearsal, a sudden jerk caused Tony Williams to exclaim “O-oHHHH-nly you” in a unique way that caught everyone’s attention. What started as a moment of laughter became the key to the song’s magic. Buck Ram, the songwriter and manager, noted that Tony’s voice “broke” during rehearsal, a spontaneous effect that was intentionally retained in the final recording. This authenticity resonated deeply with audiences.
“Only You” not only captivated American listeners but also made a significant impact internationally. When The Platters’ hit “The Great Pretender” was released in the UK, “Only You” was featured on the flipside, introducing European audiences to their soulful sound. Both songs were also showcased in the 1956 film “Rock Around the Clock,” further solidifying their popularity.
The Platters revisited “Only You” once more in 1966, recording a slightly longer version for Musicor Records, included on the album “I Love You 1,000 Times.” This rendition added another layer to the song’s rich history.
In 1999, the 1955 recording of “Only You (And You Alone)” by The Platters was rightfully inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame, a testament to its timeless appeal and the profound impact it has had on generations of music lovers.
“Only You” is more than just a song; it’s a piece of musical heritage. Its smooth, heartfelt delivery and the poignant story of its creation continue to evoke nostalgia and admiration. For many, it represents the golden era of pop music, where emotion and authenticity reigned supreme. The Platters’ rendition of “Only You” remains a beloved classic, cherished by old and new fans alike, a shining example of the enduring power of music to touch the heart and soul.