About the song
“Oh! Carol” is a timeless classic written by Neil Sedaka in 1958, co-written with Howard Greenfield. The song has become one of Sedaka’s most beloved hits, notable for its catchy melody and Sedaka’s unique spoken recitation of the verse during the second time around. This charming feature helped the song stand out and contributed to its widespread popularity.
Released as a single, “Oh! Carol” enjoyed significant chart success, spending an impressive 18 weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 and peaking at No. 9 on December 6, 1959. Its appeal was not limited to the United States, as it also climbed to No. 3 on the UK’s New Musical Express chart. The song achieved even greater international acclaim, earning Sedaka his first No. 1 ranking in both the Netherlands and Wallonia, demonstrating its universal appeal and marking a major milestone in Sedaka’s career.
The song was later included in the album *Neil Sedaka Sings Little Devil and His Other Hits*, further cementing its place in music history. Interestingly, “Carol” in the song title is a reference to Carol Klein, Sedaka’s high school girlfriend who later became famous as the iconic songwriter Carole King. Klein, who worked with Sedaka at the famed Brill Building, playfully responded to “Oh! Carol” with her own song, “Oh! Neil,” written with her husband Gerry Goffin. Although “Oh! Neil” did not achieve the same success, it adds an endearing backstory to the original song, highlighting the camaraderie and creative interplay between these legendary songwriters.
In addition to “Oh! Carol,” the single’s B-side, “One Way Ticket,” also enjoyed considerable success, particularly in Japan, where it earned Sedaka a No. 1 ranking for several months in 1960. This further demonstrates Sedaka’s ability to craft hits that resonated with audiences worldwide, showcasing his versatility and broad appeal.
Sedaka’s “Oh! Carol” remains a beloved piece of pop music history, a testament to the enduring charm and creativity of one of the era’s most talented songwriters. The song’s catchy tune, heartfelt lyrics, and the personal story behind it continue to captivate listeners, old and new. Whether it’s the nostalgic charm for those who remember its original release or the timeless appeal for new generations discovering it, “Oh! Carol” is a shining example of Neil Sedaka’s enduring legacy in the music world.
Video
Lyrics
Oh! Carol
I am but a fool
Darling, I love you
Though you treat me cruel
You hurt me
And you make me cry
But if you leave me
I will surely die
Darling, there will never be another
‘Cause I love you so
Don’t ever leave me
Say you’ll never go
I will always want you for my sweet heart
No matter what you do
Oh! Carol
I’m so in love with you
Oh! Carol
I am but a fool
Darling, I love you
Though you treat me cruel
You hurt me
And you make me cry
But if you leave me
I will surely die
Darling, there will never be another
‘Cause I love you so
Don’t ever leave me
Say you’ll never go
I will always want you for my sweet heart
No matter what you do
Oh! Carol
I’m so in love with you